The Four-Color crew is joined live and in person by Mr. John Hall and Lillian McKinney, as they gather 'round the fire to regale listeners with tales of animated superhero Christmases past:
Justice League - "Comfort & Joy," as told by Lacey Day
Batman: The Animated Series - "Christmas with the Joker," as told by John Hall
Batman: The Brave and the Bold - "Attack of the Secret Santas!" as told by Gerald James
X-Men - "Have Yourself A Morlock Little Christmas," as told by Lillian McKinney
All of this, and Gerald presents a rousing game of "Miss the Mark," as he tasks Allen, John, Lacey, and Lillian to discern between titles he made up and titles of actual Hallmark holiday specials!